Evangelicalism, American Protestantism’s most vibrant and committed religious movement, is in a bind. Overwhelmingly, self-described evangelicals supported Trump; yet almost as commonly heard as the 81 percent who made up that statistic were the 19 percent of evangelicals, many of disproportionately higher economic status, who opposed him (some of whom have now disavowed the title "evangelical" altogether). Over the last year, the division between evangelicals and their leadership has only grown, raising the question of who is driving the movement.