American liberties depend, in part, on American pluralism. But not just any pluralism will do. We need a pluralism rooted in a culture committed to the idea of truth, a culture that recognizes authority higher than individual autonomy. And, among the many liberties associated with the American story, we are here interested in a certain liberty of groups against the liberty of a democratized mass. Or, to put it as Pierre Manent does in A World Beyond Politics?, if “the idea of liberty prevail(s) completely over the idea of truth” liberty will be “deprived of its conflicting relationship with truth” and liberty will “collapse.”