Tablet Magazine is a project of Nextbook Inc. About Us | Contact | Terms of Service | RSS
Though officially an exercise in change and progress, Rahm Emanuel's inauguration as Chicago's first Jewish mayor was nonetheless steeped in well-worn myths and traditions
By Rachel Shteir | May 17, 2011 1:19 PM | Print | Email | Share
Brooke E. Collins/Chicago 2011
According to the official program for Rahm Emanuel's swearing-in ceremony yesterday, the rabbi spoke twice.
The leaflet had Jack Moline, a Chicago native who is currently the rabbi of the Agudas Achim Congregation in Alexandria, Va., offering his benediction both before and after the Chicago Children's Choir.
Perhaps listing Moline twice is Emanuel's way of reminding the city that he is its first Jewish mayor, a fact that most of the inaugural coverage will mention and then quickly drop. Or perhaps, since the rabbi actually only spoke once, it was a typo, if it is conceivable to imagine that Rahm's media staff"”which reporters here have criticized for their micro-managing"”made a mistake. The reduplication reminded me of an image that has haunted me throughout the campaign: an Emanuel caught between the old and the new. As the New York Times' Monica Davey observed in a May 16 story, however forcefully Rahm charges toward change, in Chicago, "old alliances and neighborhood tribalism are hardly forgotten."
Indeed, these tensions roiled throughout the inaugural festivities, which began on Saturday. It was raining and in the 40s that morning when Emanuel's black SUV pulled up at a community garden on Chicago's South Side. First to emerge was a staffer carrying a shovel and a pitchfork. The mayor-elect then leapt from the car and stalked around the garden in a Patagonia fleece, jeans, sneakers, and no coat. The rest of the family was there too, also coatless, though Emanuel's wife Amy had a pashmina chicly wrapped around her neck.
Mr. Mayor, is this a metaphor for rooting out political corruption? a reporter asked as Rahm began pounding his shovel into the dirt.
Sure, he replied, coming up with a shovelful of weeds, plastic, and dandelions. "If you want to see it that way."
But then he seemed to think better of it. "Is this OK to throw out?" he asked, holding up his shovel to no one in particular. When a garden staffer assured Rahm that it was, he poured the dirt gently into a wheelbarrow.
Several hours later, the rain had not abated, and a crowd of about 100 gathered in Grant Park to hear Chicago"”the ’70s supergroup that got their start here, that is.
Given Rahm's platform of change, the choice seemed, at best, counterintuitive. If you are advocating change, you might want to eliminate references to Chicago as the Windy City, the City of Big Shoulders, Chi-Town, or the City That Works or adjectives like "muscular." Or at least keep them to a minimum.
As usual, Team Rahm succeeded more with the snacks and the swag than sophistication, offering rain-drenched spectators lip balm, granola bars, bottled water, and rain ponchos.
By Monday, it was still cold but clear. Thousands gathered in Grant Park at the dazzling Frank Gehry-designed Pritzker Pavilion, the brainchild of Emanuel's immediate predecessor, Richard M. Daley. Before the ceremony, U.S. Sen. Richard Durbin, former Obama hand David Axelrod, and other high-powered pols wandered near the press tent, granting sound-bites.
Common wisdom holds that the swearing-in ceremony and inaugural address were models of diversity and testimonies to Emanuel's seriousness about change and reform.
Maybe so, but just as the band Chicago provides residents with a sentimental view of the city and its musical heritage, Rahm's inaugural address offered listeners a sentimental fable about its nickname: It is called the Second City, because, after the Chicago Fire of 1871, the residents rebuilt the city "from the ground up," he said.
That is one story about how Chicago earned its nickname, to be sure. But telling only this part of the moniker's history does everyone a disservice. The name may also have taken root when Chicago became the country's second most-populous city around 1890, and it stuck when A.J. Liebling used it as the title of a book that compared the city's residents"”unfavorably"”with New Yorkers.
Things have changed since then, of course. Chicago, as someone once pointed out to me, is not Chelm. Yet, the most recent census showed that Chicago is now third in the nation, population-wise, and shrinking. If Chicago is to change, as Rahm wishes, it will be, as Rabbi Moline said in his speech, quoting the Talmudic sage Rabbi Chanina, “because we are praying for the welfare of the government, praying that every person will help fix what is broken."
As I walked away from Pritzker Pavilion through Grant Park, I could not help but notice the many cracks lining the sidewalk.
Rachel Shteir is the author of The Steal: A Cultural History of Shoplifting, which is to be published by The Penguin Press next month.
More in: David Axelrod, Frank Gehry, Jack Moline, Monica Davey, Rahm Emanuel, Richard Durbin, Richard M. Daley, The Rahm Report
5 Responses to “Forward and Back” ricki says: May 17, 2011 at 3:02 PMPedestrian observations that are supposed to offer great insight but really amount to a whole bunch of nothing.
A Chicagoan says: May 17, 2011 at 3:07 PMRachel Shteir’s coverage of Emanuel has been consistently (and hilariously) dour since his campaign started. What’s her beef with Rahm? Is it because she predicted that Chicago would never elect a Jewish mayor?
MM says: May 17, 2011 at 3:43 PMDour is right. I was sick of Shteir’s commentary during the mayoral election and I’m sick of it now. The sidewalks have cracks everywhere, even in New York.
Tablet, please either find someone else to report on Rahm or give it up altogether.
grampsny says: May 17, 2011 at 8:09 PMI don’t understand the underlying vitriol in Ms. Shteir’s writing. She sounds like the only thing that would please her would be the Mayor’s renunciation of his Judaism. My Mother would have said…”it’s a shanda”. My Father would have said…”Feh! I say…If you are a reporter covering such an important event, then report. If you are a purported bylined columnist, write with some class. She sounds like she is writing for an anti-Semetic publication. Is she ashamed of the Mayor’s religion? Does she also cringe at the annual NYC Diocese roasts? Would she have been more comfortable with a Father Coughlan doing the benediction? Tell her that Jews have come out of the closet! grampsny
Who cares says: May 18, 2011 at 12:11 AMA powerful Jewish man with a shiksa wife and gentile children. So what else is new?
Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply.Name (required)
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
2000 Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words.HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment.
var charCount = 0; var oldString = ""; var newString = ""; jQuery("#submit").click(function(){ if ( jQuery("#comment").val().length > 2000){ alert("Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words."); return false; } return true; }); jQuery("#comment").keyup(function(){ charCount = 2000 - jQuery("#comment").val().length; $("#charTitle .charError").remove(); if ( charCount == 0 ){ $("#charCounter").html('0'); } else if ( charCount < 0 ){ oldString = jQuery("#comment").val(); newString = oldString.slice(0,2000); jQuery("#comment").val(newString); $("#charTitle").append('Too many characters, your comment has been shortened to 2,000 characters.'); $("#charCounter").html('0'); } else { $("#charCounter").css("color","000"); $("#charCounter").html(charCount); } }); Hall of MirrorsA new book tells the story of a middle-class Jewish girl from Westchester who changed her name, moved to Pakistan, and became a leading voice of radical Islamism
Court JewNBA coach and commentator Jeff Van Gundy is not Jewish, but his brainy banter, nebbishy looks, and nervous intensity have led fans to think otherwise
His Jewish ProblemA few years ago, Israel Shamir's anti-Israel vitriol would have been marginal and largely ignored. But in the age of WikiLeaks, a Holocaust-doubter can become a legitimate source of news. Part 2 of 2.
Your email address: Your email address is not valid
Recipient's email address: Recipient email address is not valid
Message (optional):
Your email has been sent.
Click here to send another
SEND X Close
Tablet Magazine In Your Inbox Nextbook Press /*jQuery(document).ready(function(){ swfobject.embedSWF("http://www.tabletmag.com/flash/NBP_Hillel-200x170.swf", "nbpFlash", "200", "170", "9", "expressInstall.swf"); });*/ Sacred TrashAdina Hoffman & Peter Cole
The amazing discovery that revolutionized our idea of Jewish life and history.
In The News Skirt Shorts
Denim defined fashion for a generation of frum schoolgirls, who played with Orthodoxy's rules of modesty through small acts of sartorial rebellion. A slideshow of one woman's beskirted past.
Pact or Fiction
The recent rapprochement between Fatah and Hamas may be a blessing. It exposes the fatal flaw at the heart of the peace process: the West's fantasy of Palestinian moderation.
Testing the Limits
Not only is standardized testing plaguing our schools, driving us to cheat, and making our children sick; it’s completely antithetical to Jewish values
Popular on TabletReadCommentedShared Skirt ShortsDenim defined fashion for a generation of frum schoolgirls, who played with Orthodoxy's rules of modesty through small acts of sartorial rebellion. A slideshow of one woman's beskirted past.
A Very Special MessageDavid Mamet draws a cartoon Pact or FictionThe recent rapprochement between Fatah and Hamas may be a blessing. It exposes the fatal flaw at the heart of the peace process: the West's fantasy of Palestinian moderation.
His Jewish ProblemIsrael Shamir is a slippery Holocaust-doubter whose anti-Semitic, anti-Israel views are"”in the age of WikiLeaks"”finding a new audience. Part 1 of 2.
Traditional Jewish Food: A DefenseSome of us are actually okay with who we are and what we eat Pact or FictionThe recent rapprochement between Fatah and Hamas may be a blessing. It exposes the fatal flaw at the heart of the peace process: the West's fantasy of Palestinian moderation.
His Jewish ProblemIsrael Shamir is a slippery Holocaust-doubter whose anti-Semitic, anti-Israel views are"”in the age of WikiLeaks"”finding a new audience. Part 1 of 2.
Traditional Jewish Food: A DefenseSome of us are actually okay with who we are and what we eat Ron Paul's Ugly PastGOP candidate has appealing features, unappealing history of race- and Jew-baiting Polyester BridesBi
Brooke E. Collins/Chicago 2011
According to the official program for Rahm Emanuel's swearing-in ceremony yesterday, the rabbi spoke twice.
The leaflet had Jack Moline, a Chicago native who is currently the rabbi of the Agudas Achim Congregation in Alexandria, Va., offering his benediction both before and after the Chicago Children's Choir.
Perhaps listing Moline twice is Emanuel's way of reminding the city that he is its first Jewish mayor, a fact that most of the inaugural coverage will mention and then quickly drop. Or perhaps, since the rabbi actually only spoke once, it was a typo, if it is conceivable to imagine that Rahm's media staff"”which reporters here have criticized for their micro-managing"”made a mistake. The reduplication reminded me of an image that has haunted me throughout the campaign: an Emanuel caught between the old and the new. As the New York Times' Monica Davey observed in a May 16 story, however forcefully Rahm charges toward change, in Chicago, "old alliances and neighborhood tribalism are hardly forgotten."
Indeed, these tensions roiled throughout the inaugural festivities, which began on Saturday. It was raining and in the 40s that morning when Emanuel's black SUV pulled up at a community garden on Chicago's South Side. First to emerge was a staffer carrying a shovel and a pitchfork. The mayor-elect then leapt from the car and stalked around the garden in a Patagonia fleece, jeans, sneakers, and no coat. The rest of the family was there too, also coatless, though Emanuel's wife Amy had a pashmina chicly wrapped around her neck.
Mr. Mayor, is this a metaphor for rooting out political corruption? a reporter asked as Rahm began pounding his shovel into the dirt.
Sure, he replied, coming up with a shovelful of weeds, plastic, and dandelions. "If you want to see it that way."
But then he seemed to think better of it. "Is this OK to throw out?" he asked, holding up his shovel to no one in particular. When a garden staffer assured Rahm that it was, he poured the dirt gently into a wheelbarrow.
Several hours later, the rain had not abated, and a crowd of about 100 gathered in Grant Park to hear Chicago"”the ’70s supergroup that got their start here, that is.
Given Rahm's platform of change, the choice seemed, at best, counterintuitive. If you are advocating change, you might want to eliminate references to Chicago as the Windy City, the City of Big Shoulders, Chi-Town, or the City That Works or adjectives like "muscular." Or at least keep them to a minimum.
As usual, Team Rahm succeeded more with the snacks and the swag than sophistication, offering rain-drenched spectators lip balm, granola bars, bottled water, and rain ponchos.
By Monday, it was still cold but clear. Thousands gathered in Grant Park at the dazzling Frank Gehry-designed Pritzker Pavilion, the brainchild of Emanuel's immediate predecessor, Richard M. Daley. Before the ceremony, U.S. Sen. Richard Durbin, former Obama hand David Axelrod, and other high-powered pols wandered near the press tent, granting sound-bites.
Common wisdom holds that the swearing-in ceremony and inaugural address were models of diversity and testimonies to Emanuel's seriousness about change and reform.
Maybe so, but just as the band Chicago provides residents with a sentimental view of the city and its musical heritage, Rahm's inaugural address offered listeners a sentimental fable about its nickname: It is called the Second City, because, after the Chicago Fire of 1871, the residents rebuilt the city "from the ground up," he said.
That is one story about how Chicago earned its nickname, to be sure. But telling only this part of the moniker's history does everyone a disservice. The name may also have taken root when Chicago became the country's second most-populous city around 1890, and it stuck when A.J. Liebling used it as the title of a book that compared the city's residents"”unfavorably"”with New Yorkers.
Things have changed since then, of course. Chicago, as someone once pointed out to me, is not Chelm. Yet, the most recent census showed that Chicago is now third in the nation, population-wise, and shrinking. If Chicago is to change, as Rahm wishes, it will be, as Rabbi Moline said in his speech, quoting the Talmudic sage Rabbi Chanina, “because we are praying for the welfare of the government, praying that every person will help fix what is broken."
As I walked away from Pritzker Pavilion through Grant Park, I could not help but notice the many cracks lining the sidewalk.
Rachel Shteir is the author of The Steal: A Cultural History of Shoplifting, which is to be published by The Penguin Press next month.
More in: David Axelrod, Frank Gehry, Jack Moline, Monica Davey, Rahm Emanuel, Richard Durbin, Richard M. Daley, The Rahm Report
Pedestrian observations that are supposed to offer great insight but really amount to a whole bunch of nothing.
Rachel Shteir’s coverage of Emanuel has been consistently (and hilariously) dour since his campaign started. What’s her beef with Rahm? Is it because she predicted that Chicago would never elect a Jewish mayor?
Dour is right. I was sick of Shteir’s commentary during the mayoral election and I’m sick of it now. The sidewalks have cracks everywhere, even in New York.
Tablet, please either find someone else to report on Rahm or give it up altogether.
I don’t understand the underlying vitriol in Ms. Shteir’s writing. She sounds like the only thing that would please her would be the Mayor’s renunciation of his Judaism. My Mother would have said…”it’s a shanda”. My Father would have said…”Feh! I say…If you are a reporter covering such an important event, then report. If you are a purported bylined columnist, write with some class. She sounds like she is writing for an anti-Semetic publication. Is she ashamed of the Mayor’s religion? Does she also cringe at the annual NYC Diocese roasts? Would she have been more comfortable with a Father Coughlan doing the benediction? Tell her that Jews have come out of the closet! grampsny
A powerful Jewish man with a shiksa wife and gentile children. So what else is new?
Name (required)
Read Full Article »