NCR classifieds - Twitter - Facebook - Email Alerts - RSS
For me, the word "confession" conjures up images of dark booths with dark mesh screens -- a private place where dark deeds can be made undone away from the light. I've been Catholic all my life; I can't help it.
But that's not the image of confession for most Americans now -- maybe not even most Catholics. This very private sacrament continues its decline, and I've got to think there's one prominent person who's partly to blame: Oprah Winfrey.
This month, Winfrey ends her 25 year reign as the top talk-show host on broadcast television. But, as Mary McNamara points out in the Los Angeles Times, Winfrey's impact goes much deeper. She changed the image of confession.
McNamara points to an episode of the talk show in 1987, when Oprah revealed she had been a victim of sexual abuse as a child. She shattered "the fourth wall" between subject and interviewer, and shifted dramatically what we expected to view on television.
More than that, though, Oprah shifted how we viewed television itself -- she changed what we as a society perceived as television's role in our lives and what it could do for us. It transformed from "the idiot box" into a confessional booth, but on a national (and very public) scale.
Post-Oprah, the notion that confession is something private, something hidden, became hopelessly medieval. In America today, confession is best done in public: shame is gone, replaced by more therapeutic bywords like "closure" and "catharsis."
In all my time working in television (both on the news side and the entertainment side), it's never ceased to amaze me what Americans are willing to talk about in front of cameras and lights. It's tempting to think of this rush to public confession as a low-brow grasp for fifteen minutes of fame, but I've come to realize it was something different, and deeper.
Television, I think, validates the struggle a person has gone through. The fact that someone wants to hear your story, believes something can be learned from it, and wants to put it out there in front of a national audience -- all these things help give personal misfortune a wider meaning. We feel the tragedy we have endured. The missteps we have made are not so random.
That's what Oprah has done. She changed a medium, no doubt -- but she also changed the meaning of a sacrament that dates back millennia: confession.
Oprah did make it popular but Confession in public goes back a little further to AA which started before Oprah was born. 'The telling of the story' goes back even further to biblical times..
This is a really good point, especially with the rise of reality tv. It's very telling that shows like Survivor feature a "confessional booth" where contestants can air their grievances or explain mistakes. Tyra Banks practically insists that her aspiring "America's Next Top Models" all have some epiphany where they admit to some bad habit or lifelong medical struggle.
On the other hand, this article glosses over the fact that public admission of sin is a long-standing Catholic tradition - what else would you call the communal confiteor at every Mass?
Are you suggesting that we should allow for an option in the rite of the sacrament for public confessions as were normative before 800-1000?
OK Joe, both you and I have the same personal experience of "confession". However let's not say: "Oprah has changed a medium, no doubt -- but she also changed the meaning of a sacrament that dates back millennia: confession."
The experience of "our confession" goes back only a couple hundred years at the most. Penance as a Sacrament in the Christian Church has a very convoluted and controversial history and I would venture an educated guess that in these past 80 some years of my own Catholic life, "confession" has continued to experience equally controversial changes, even without the aid of this Orpha person whom "I must confess" I have never seen or heard on TV.
So let's not throw in the towel. Our Second Vatican Council has tried to bring us back into focus with the life-plan of Jesus of Nazareth and the only reason for the existence of the Christian Church: "Our Father, thy Kingdom come on earth as it is heaven.,,,". Since we are all sisters and brothers, let's get on with our work for that Kingdom, that "other possible society", that "other possible world", different from our lopsided current world of tremendous inequality where one of our sisters or brothers dies of hunger every four seconds and our own Dear Mother Earth is being treated disgracefully because of our greed.
Justiniano de Managua
More information about formatting options
Read Full Article »