Tablet Magazine is a project of Nextbook Inc. About Us | Contact | Terms of Service | RSS
By Marc Tracy | Sep 21, 2010 4:19 PM | Print | Email | TweetShare
Martin Peretz.
Wikipedia
This is the post I've been avoiding. Writing about Martin Peretz, the editor-in-chief and part-owner of The New Republic, and his recent comment, "Muslim life is cheap, most notably to Muslims," seemed useless and dispiriting for any number of reasons. For one thing, plenty of others had their say (see here, here, and most prominently here). Additionally, some have defended Peretz (see here and here) on the grounds that, for all his faults, he has been an extremely valuable political and journalistic participant for four decades due to his patronage of the fantastic New Republic. Most importantly, there is not much to say: Unlike when most writers write something objectionable, and you can ask, "Why the hell is that Website publishing that writer?," well, in this case we already knew the answer: Peretz is the boss, and as anyone with a boss knows"”and nearly everybody has a boss"”you do what your boss wants.
News, however, that Harvard's Social Studies Department dropped him as a speaker at its upcoming 50th anniversary celebration forces the issue.
And the issue is this: Despite Peretz's legalistic retraction (albeit of a different sentence, regarding not extending First Amendment protections to Muslims) and sincere atonement"”his Kol Nidre and his Yom Kippur, if you will"”this is not the first time he has written something racist, and it isn't the fifteenth time, either. While I am not sure if this was the best choice of medium, someone has made a Twitter feed documenting the dozens of questionable"”no, make that unquestionably out-of-bounds"”things Peretz has said over the years. We all publish things we would take back. But the tonnage of these quotations and the consistency of their content demonstrate that Peretz's insensitivity and bigotry toward Muslims and Arabs (er, and black people) yank him out of the realm of people you should be reading on the subject.
So whom should you be reading? Today Todd Gitlin eloquently argued that Peretz's latest comment came at exactly the wrong time. "When the margins crawl with insanity," he wrote, "it is all the more important for the vital center of calm, reasonable, evidence-based thought to hold." Where is that vital center? You could start with where Gitlin’s essay was published: The New Republic. You could continue with the best thing you will read concerning the Islamic center, which was published in … The New Republic. See my point? It will be a tremendous shame if a reader were to stop taking Peretz’s magazine seriously just because he has (correctly) stopped taking Peretz’s own writing seriously. But even though such a reader would be the one to blame for that decision, I hope Peretz would find it regrettable, and I hope he will do his part to prevent it from happening. In a word: Stop.
Peretz Dropped As Harvard Event Speaker [JTA] Related: This Manichean Moment [TNR] @martyperetz [Twitter]
More in: Martin Peretz, The New Republic, Todd Gitlin
2 Responses to “Harvard Cancels Peretz Speech” jzsnake says: Sep 21, 2010 at 8:31 PMIt’s amazing how Universities will invite Arabs/Muslims to speak who say the most vile statements about Jews.
James Prater says: Sep 21, 2010 at 9:35 PMJzsnake, I dont understand it either. I am an american and get so disgusted with all the vile things they say about us too and yet the government coddles to them !!! There has never been a more vile race of people since Hitlers Germany. But I also know there is a tremendous amount of people who are not afraid to speak up against this tyranny and those that let it happen. I am hoping that the election in 2010 will prove to the world that the jewish and christian people are still n control of America, not the idiots or the muslims.
Leave a Reply Click here to cancel reply.Name (required)
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
2000 Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words.HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment.
var charCount = 0; var oldString = ""; var newString = ""; jQuery("#submit").click(function(){ if ( jQuery("#comment").val().length > 2000){ alert("Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words."); return false; } return true; }); jQuery("#comment").keyup(function(){ charCount = 2000 - jQuery("#comment").val().length; $("#charTitle .charError").remove(); if ( charCount == 0 ){ $("#charCounter").html('0'); } else if ( charCount < 0 ){ oldString = jQuery("#comment").val(); newString = oldString.slice(0,2000); jQuery("#comment").val(newString); $("#charTitle").append('Too many characters, your comment has been shortened to 2,000 characters.'); $("#charCounter").html('0'); } else { $("#charCounter").css("color","000"); $("#charCounter").html(charCount); } }); Sundown: Ayalon and Fayyad Don't Play NicePlus Peres and Barak paint the town red, and more
"Nobody Knew He Was an Agent for the Israelis'Your Vox Tablet preview
Sukkah of the SoulWhat would you take inside?
Your email address: Your email address is not valid
Recipient's email address: Recipient email address is not valid
Message (optional):
Your email has been sent.
Click here to send another
SEND X Close
Tablet Magazine In Your Inbox Nextbook Press Hillel: If Not Now, When?Joseph Telushkin NEW. A bold new look at an iconic religious leader.
Video Joseph Telushkin on Hillel
All current titles » Popular on TabletReadCommentedShared Sacred RemakeWe may talk of its eternal qualities, but the music of Kol Nidre is forever being made anew "ANTM' Contestant To Forego ObservanceTyra Banks show stages Modern Orthodox drama First DraftEnvisioning a rabbi's struggle to write an original Yom Kippur sermon Shmuley and ChristopherA rabbi and an atheist walk into a room " Kosher by DesignHow Michael Wyschogrod taught me to eat like a Jew "ANTM' Contestant To Forego ObservanceTyra Banks show stages Modern Orthodox drama Lost in TranslationA Ramallah man struggles to find a reading public for Maimonides Kosher by DesignHow Michael Wyschogrod taught me to eat like a Jew The Grave OutdoorsTo the neurotic urban parent, Sukkot might as well be called Booths of Death Sacred RemakeWe may talk of its eternal qualities, but the music of Kol Nidre is forever being made anew
Copyright 2010 Nextbook Inc. All rights reserved. Home | Arts & Culture | Life & Religion | News & Politics | The Scroll | About Tablet Magazine | About Nextbook Inc. | Contact | Terms of Service | Tablet RSS
/* */ var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); try { var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-5586805-2"); pageTracker._trackPageview(); } catch(err) {}Martin Peretz.
Wikipedia
This is the post I've been avoiding. Writing about Martin Peretz, the editor-in-chief and part-owner of The New Republic, and his recent comment, "Muslim life is cheap, most notably to Muslims," seemed useless and dispiriting for any number of reasons. For one thing, plenty of others had their say (see here, here, and most prominently here). Additionally, some have defended Peretz (see here and here) on the grounds that, for all his faults, he has been an extremely valuable political and journalistic participant for four decades due to his patronage of the fantastic New Republic. Most importantly, there is not much to say: Unlike when most writers write something objectionable, and you can ask, "Why the hell is that Website publishing that writer?," well, in this case we already knew the answer: Peretz is the boss, and as anyone with a boss knows"”and nearly everybody has a boss"”you do what your boss wants.
News, however, that Harvard's Social Studies Department dropped him as a speaker at its upcoming 50th anniversary celebration forces the issue.
And the issue is this: Despite Peretz's legalistic retraction (albeit of a different sentence, regarding not extending First Amendment protections to Muslims) and sincere atonement"”his Kol Nidre and his Yom Kippur, if you will"”this is not the first time he has written something racist, and it isn't the fifteenth time, either. While I am not sure if this was the best choice of medium, someone has made a Twitter feed documenting the dozens of questionable"”no, make that unquestionably out-of-bounds"”things Peretz has said over the years. We all publish things we would take back. But the tonnage of these quotations and the consistency of their content demonstrate that Peretz's insensitivity and bigotry toward Muslims and Arabs (er, and black people) yank him out of the realm of people you should be reading on the subject.
So whom should you be reading? Today Todd Gitlin eloquently argued that Peretz's latest comment came at exactly the wrong time. "When the margins crawl with insanity," he wrote, "it is all the more important for the vital center of calm, reasonable, evidence-based thought to hold." Where is that vital center? You could start with where Gitlin’s essay was published: The New Republic. You could continue with the best thing you will read concerning the Islamic center, which was published in … The New Republic. See my point? It will be a tremendous shame if a reader were to stop taking Peretz’s magazine seriously just because he has (correctly) stopped taking Peretz’s own writing seriously. But even though such a reader would be the one to blame for that decision, I hope Peretz would find it regrettable, and I hope he will do his part to prevent it from happening. In a word: Stop.
Peretz Dropped As Harvard Event Speaker [JTA] Related: This Manichean Moment [TNR] @martyperetz [Twitter]
More in: Martin Peretz, The New Republic, Todd Gitlin
It’s amazing how Universities will invite Arabs/Muslims to speak who say the most vile statements about Jews.
Jzsnake, I dont understand it either. I am an american and get so disgusted with all the vile things they say about us too and yet the government coddles to them !!! There has never been a more vile race of people since Hitlers Germany. But I also know there is a tremendous amount of people who are not afraid to speak up against this tyranny and those that let it happen. I am hoping that the election in 2010 will prove to the world that the jewish and christian people are still n control of America, not the idiots or the muslims.
Name (required)
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Website
XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
2000 Your comment may be no longer than 2,000 characters, approximately 400 words.HTML tags are not permitted, nor are more than two URLs per comment.
Plus Peres and Barak paint the town red, and more
Your Vox Tablet preview
What would you take inside?
Your email address: Your email address is not valid
Recipient's email address: Recipient email address is not valid
Message (optional):
Your email has been sent.
Click here to send another
SEND X Close
Joseph Telushkin NEW. A bold new look at an iconic religious leader.
Video Joseph Telushkin on Hillel
Read Full Article »