Imam Feisal Abdul RaufImam Feisal Abdul Rauf, the man behind the proposed Islamic center near Ground Zero, is traveling through the Middle East at the request of the State Department. As part of this ambassadorial tour, he has given an interview to the National of Abu Dhabi, published yesterday, in which he responds to questions about the U.S. uproar over his project. Are his answers adequate? Let's take a look.
1. Much of the reaction is just politics. "There is no doubt that the election season has had a major impact upon the nature of the discourse," the imam says. This implies that the intensity of the backlash will subside once the November elections are over"”and that time is what's needed to cool the resistance. We'll see whether this bet proves wise.
2. The backlash is normal. "The struggles we are going through today are of the same genre as what the previous faith communities had to face," he says. "Jewish immigrants, Catholic immigrants had to face even worse attacks against their communities." But "as the second generation establishes itself and is rooted in the United States they articulate an expression of who we are as Americans and [are] seen decreasingly as alien." This point is similar to the previous one: Time will dissolve much of the resistance. But here, the imam is no longer talking about a single election. He's talking about generations. He's saying that after the election is over, the remaining, underlying distrust of Muslims will ultimately be healed only by the slow process of integration. The upside of this prognosis is that in the long run, history favors healing.
3. This is a local matter. "The local community board recognizes and understands the vision, the politicians in New York understand the vision, and there is broad-based support for these objectives," says the imam. In a separate talk in Bahrain, he told a questioner, "The opposition to us has come from outside the community." He's right, but this is a risky tack. A man who was born outside the United States (he's a naturalized citizen), speaks English with an accent, and preaches a minority religion that was invoked by the 9/11 plotters is claiming insider status against Christian, native-born Americans. This might work in the ethnic mixing bowl of New York. But in the broader United States, it sounds pretty crazy.
4. He probably should have picked a different site. Abdul Rauf never says this. But the National reports, "When asked about whether he would have chosen a different location for the project if he knew in advance about the controversy, Imam Feisal said the Prophet Mohammad instructed Muslims not to dwell on past decisions and wonder about alternative outcomes." Translation: Oops! Similarly, in a CBS News interview that aired Monday, the project's developer, Sharif El-Gamal, has this exchange:
Q: Did it occur to you when you were putting this together that that was two blocks too close to a place that many, many people feel very strongly about? El-Gamal: Not at all. It did not even cross my mind once. Q: Why not? El-Gamal: Because I did not hold myself or my faith accountable for that tragedy.
The takeaway from these interviews seems pretty clear: Neither man appreciated the political risks of the site they chose. If they had, they would have handled things quite differently.
5. The real fight is between moderates and radicals. Abdul Rauf says the struggle now "is not between Muslims and non-Muslims, but between moderates of all the faith traditions and the radicals of all the faith traditions. So what is required is a coalition." He says Muslim radicals and anti-Muslim radicals "feed off each other and need each other to sustain themselves. So we need right now to combat the radical voices." This is the crux of the whole debate, and here, the imam is exactly right. Witness the eerily similar, mutually reinforcing fulminations of Osama Bin Laden and Newt Gingrich. When Abdul Rauf returns to the United States, this is the point he needs to emphasize: In the mosque debate, we should side not with one faith against another, but with moderation against radicalism.
6. The backlash justifies going ahead with the plan. "The fact that there has been this misunderstanding shows the need for the project," says the imam. Well, yes. But does it show the need for building the project at the presently planned site? It's safer to point out simply that the backlash is unjustified and that the project will help ameliorate the underlying distrust.
7. Religious pluralism is Islam. Our basic rights, enumerated in the Declaration of Independence, reflect a "foundational viewpoint of America" that "is exactly what Islam is," says the imam. He asserts that the American principle "that religious liberty is a fundamental protected right" is "a value which lies at the very core of the Quranic value."
Really? Freedom of religion is at the core of Islam? That strikes me as wildly implausible. It certainly isn't true of Judaism or Christianity. These are religions, not neutral referees. They try to run your life. The imam, too, believes that Islam should run the lives of Muslims. Yet he suggests that Islamic law is a perfect fit, if not a synonym, for American pluralism. Gingrich disputes this, and here, Gingrich seems to have the better argument. When the imam returns, he has a lot of explaining to do.Like Slate on Facebook. Follow us on Twitter. William Saletan's latest short takes on the news, via Twitter:Latest Twitter UpdatesFollow William Saletan on Twitter.
0 CommentsAdd Yours Or join the discussionon the Fray #outbrain_widget_cntr{ background-color:white; border-top:solid 1px #ccc; border-bottom:solid 1px #ccc; width:568px; margin:16px 0 15px 36px; padding:5px 0; font-size:0.9em; } #outbrain_widget_cntr h4{ text-transform:uppercase; margin:5px; } #outbrain_widget_cntr div.ob_rec h4{ font-size:1.1em!important; color:#603; } #outbrain_widget_cntr div.ob_sl h4{ color:#333; } #outbrain_widget_cntr ul{ padding:0; } #outbrain_widget_cntr ul li{ margin:5px 15px; list-style-type:disc!important; } #outbrain_widget_cntr div.ob_sl{ width:283px; height:100%; border-left:solid 1px #ccc; } More from Slate var OutbrainPermaLink = 'http://www.slate.com/id/2265607'; var OB_Template = "SlateMag"; var OBITm = '1279047491872'; if ( typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined' ){ OutbrainStart(); } else { var OB_Script = true; document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='http://widgets.outbrain.com/OutbrainRater.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); } More from the Web digg_url = 'http://www.slate.com/id/2265607'; digg_window = 'new'; slate:http://www.slate.com//id/2265607 //temp override for the hive document.getElementById("twittertoolanc").href = "http://twitter.com/home?status=" + document.title + ' - ' + window.location; //temp override for the hive document.getElementById("fbtoolanc").href = "http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=" + window.location + '&t=' + document.title; slate:http://www.slate.com/id/2265607/ Facebook Digg RedditStumbleUponCLOSEWilliam Saletan is Slate's national correspondent and author of Bearing Right: How Conservatives Won the Abortion War. Follow him on Twitter here. Photograph of Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf by Hasan Jamali/AFP/Getty Images. adsonar_placementId=1413511; adsonar_pid=833771; adsonar_ps=-1; adsonar_zw=539; adsonar_zh=90; adsonar_jv='ads.adsonar.com'; SlateDom.addListener(window,'load',SlateComments.loadEcho) adsonar_placementId=1406283; adsonar_pid=833771; adsonar_ps=-1; adsonar_zw=538; adsonar_zh=250; adsonar_jv='ads.adsonar.com';SPONSORED CONTENT var pl = "bottom"; var anc = document.getElementById('bizbox_links_' + pl).getElementsByTagName("a")[0]; anc.innerHTML = bizbox_latest_title; anc.href = bizbox_latest_href; placeAd2(commercialNode,'rightflex',false,'')Also in SlateApplebaum: Five Ways the Iraq War Weakened America Does the Imam Behind the "Ground Zero Mosque" Have Any Regrets?Ruth Bader Ginsburg Was the Original Mama GrizzlyKiss These States Goodbye, Senate Democrats adsonar_placementId=1406226; adsonar_pid=833771; adsonar_ps=-1; adsonar_zw=336; adsonar_zh=250; adsonar_jv='ads.adsonar.com';placeAd2(commercialNode,'mostread',false,'') var adOptions = [{ width: 'auto', height: 'auto', container: 'WPL-CS-Widget', divClass: 'wl_widget wl_teaser_ad wp', crossSite: 'true' }]; var rev_domscript = document.createElement('script'); rev_domscript.src = "http://media3.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/wapolabs/cdn/prod/1_1/js/rev_platform_ads_setup.js"; document.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].appendChild(rev_domscript);placeAd2(commercialNode,'336x90',false,'')placeAd2(commercialNode,'336x90|2',false,'')TODAY'S PICTURESTODAY'S CARTOONSTODAY'S DOONESBURYTODAY'S VIDEOThe end of summer.Cartoonists' take on the Israel-Palestine conflict.Not-feeling-the-love handle.runMobileCompatibilityScript('homepagePlayer','homepagePlayer');TodaysMedia.init(); MostLiked RecentlyShared Like Slate on FacebookFBOpenGraph.init();More Frame Game columnsThe Imam SpeaksFeisal Abdul Rauf defends his plan for an Islamic center near Ground Zero.William Saletan | Aug. 31, 2010It's Good To Be KingDon't ridicule Glenn Beck's tribute to MLK. Celebrate it.William Saletan | Aug. 30, 2010Gay-O-PBush's GOP chairman comes out of the closet. Can he change the gay marriage debate?William Saletan | Aug. 26, 2010Search for more Frame Game articlesSubscribe to the Frame Game RSS feedView our complete Frame Game archiveplaceAd2(commercialNode,'bigbox|2',false,'')ÂTroy Polamalu's hair is insured for $1 million. Here's how body-part insurance works http://slate.me/9VcOsL
ÂDesigning Obama, free online. http://slate.me/dv1JzY
ÂBemoaning the loss of math skills among Americans ... in 1804. http://slate.me/dn5XBA
 placeAd2(commercialNode,'twitter',false,'')Obama's Iraq Speech: Expect it to be Sober and Low KeyPOLL: Majority of GOP Believes Obama Wants Worldwide Islamic LawTroops to President Obama: Thank You, Mr. PresidentIn Praise of Offshore DrillingColonel: I Got Kicked Out of Afghanistan for Speaking the TruthInheriting Iraq: Images from the War Obama Didn't WantLatin American Democracies Lash Out at the PressWikipedia: A New Battleground in the Israeli-Palestinian ConflictPresident Obama's Oval Office RemodelWATCH: Meghan McCain's 'Dirty Sexy Politics'WATCH: Arrests on a United Airlines FlightWATCH: U.S. Prepares for Earl's Arrivalfeatured advertiser linksDon't risk your credit. Know where you stand.Protect your credit with Equifax Complete. Recommended For You var OB_multi_MP_url= 'http://www.slate.com'; var OB_multi_MP_count = 5; var OB_ads_only = true; var OB_ads_only_what_is_outbrain_str ="[What's This?]"; SPONSORED CONTENT var pl = "right_rail"; var anc = document.getElementById('bizbox_links_' + pl).getElementsByTagName("a")[0]; anc.innerHTML = bizbox_latest_title; anc.href = bizbox_latest_href; ClickTrax.init();Applebaum: Five Ways the Iraq War Weakened America Ruth Bader Ginsburg Was the Original Mama GrizzlyWho Was Really the First To Call Journalism "the First Rough Draft of History"?Kiss These States Goodbye, Senate DemocratsHow To Keep Your Spirits Up When You're Trapped in a MineHow Do They Count Crowds Like the One at Glenn Beck's Rally?placeAd2(commercialNode,'leaderboard|2',false,'');site map | build your own Slate | the fray | about us | contact us | Slate on Facebook | searchfeedback | help | advertise | newsletters | mobile | make Slate your homepage© Copyright 2010 Washington Post.Newsweek Interactive Co. LLCUser Agreement and Privacy Policy | All rights reservedBF_BB_DATA = null;(function( ){document.write('');var sid="77FMJ7";var c=""; var b="";BF_BB_SCRIPT=document.createElement('script'); BF_BB_SCRIPT.type="text/javascript";BF_BB_SRC="http://buzzbox.buzzfeed.com/wd/BuzzBox?sid=" + sid + c + b + '&it=1&cb=' + (new Date()).getTime();setTimeout(function() { document.getElementById('BF_BUZZBOX').appendChild(BF_BB_SCRIPT); BF_BB_SCRIPT.src=BF_BB_SRC; },1);})(); var SlateComments = {}; SlateComments.loadEcho = function() { var script1 = document.createElement('script') script1.src = 'http://js-kit.com/for/slate.com/comments.js'; document.body.appendChild(script1) } document.domain = 'slate.com';checkVisitorId( 'slate.com' );selectMostTab('2');_qoptions={qacct:"p-5cYn7dCzvaeyA"}; if (typeof $ == 'function') { $(document).ready(function() { window._sf_endpt=(new Date()).getTime(); var e = document.createElement('script'); e.setAttribute('language', 'javascript'); e.setAttribute('type', 'text/javascript'); e.setAttribute('src', (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://s3.amazonaws.com/" : "http://") + "static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat.js"); document.body.appendChild(e); }); } document.domain = "slate.com"; Meebo('domReady'); TodaysMedia.init(); MostLiked RecentlyShared Like Slate on FacebookFBOpenGraph.init();More Frame Game columnsThe Imam SpeaksFeisal Abdul Rauf defends his plan for an Islamic center near Ground Zero.William Saletan | Aug. 31, 2010It's Good To Be KingDon't ridicule Glenn Beck's tribute to MLK. Celebrate it.William Saletan | Aug. 30, 2010Gay-O-PBush's GOP chairman comes out of the closet. Can he change the gay marriage debate?William Saletan | Aug. 26, 2010Search for more Frame Game articlesSubscribe to the Frame Game RSS feedView our complete Frame Game archiveplaceAd2(commercialNode,'bigbox|2',false,'')ÂTroy Polamalu's hair is insured for $1 million. Here's how body-part insurance works http://slate.me/9VcOsL
ÂDesigning Obama, free online. http://slate.me/dv1JzY
ÂBemoaning the loss of math skills among Americans ... in 1804. http://slate.me/dn5XBA
 placeAd2(commercialNode,'twitter',false,'')Obama's Iraq Speech: Expect it to be Sober and Low KeyPOLL: Majority of GOP Believes Obama Wants Worldwide Islamic LawTroops to President Obama: Thank You, Mr. PresidentIn Praise of Offshore DrillingColonel: I Got Kicked Out of Afghanistan for Speaking the TruthInheriting Iraq: Images from the War Obama Didn't WantLatin American Democracies Lash Out at the PressWikipedia: A New Battleground in the Israeli-Palestinian ConflictPresident Obama's Oval Office RemodelWATCH: Meghan McCain's 'Dirty Sexy Politics'WATCH: Arrests on a United Airlines FlightWATCH: U.S. Prepares for Earl's Arrivalfeatured advertiser linksDon't risk your credit. Know where you stand.Protect your credit with Equifax Complete. Recommended For You var OB_multi_MP_url= 'http://www.slate.com'; var OB_multi_MP_count = 5; var OB_ads_only = true; var OB_ads_only_what_is_outbrain_str ="[What's This?]"; SPONSORED CONTENT var pl = "right_rail"; var anc = document.getElementById('bizbox_links_' + pl).getElementsByTagName("a")[0]; anc.innerHTML = bizbox_latest_title; anc.href = bizbox_latest_href; ClickTrax.init();Applebaum: Five Ways the Iraq War Weakened America Ruth Bader Ginsburg Was the Original Mama GrizzlyWho Was Really the First To Call Journalism "the First Rough Draft of History"?Kiss These States Goodbye, Senate DemocratsHow To Keep Your Spirits Up When You're Trapped in a MineHow Do They Count Crowds Like the One at Glenn Beck's Rally?placeAd2(commercialNode,'leaderboard|2',false,'');site map | build your own Slate | the fray | about us | contact us | Slate on Facebook | searchfeedback | help | advertise | newsletters | mobile | make Slate your homepage© Copyright 2010 Washington Post.Newsweek Interactive Co. LLCUser Agreement and Privacy Policy | All rights reservedBF_BB_DATA = null;(function( ){document.write('');var sid="77FMJ7";var c=""; var b="";BF_BB_SCRIPT=document.createElement('script'); BF_BB_SCRIPT.type="text/javascript";BF_BB_SRC="http://buzzbox.buzzfeed.com/wd/BuzzBox?sid=" + sid + c + b + '&it=1&cb=' + (new Date()).getTime();setTimeout(function() { document.getElementById('BF_BUZZBOX').appendChild(BF_BB_SCRIPT); BF_BB_SCRIPT.src=BF_BB_SRC; },1);})(); var SlateComments = {}; SlateComments.loadEcho = function() { var script1 = document.createElement('script') script1.src = 'http://js-kit.com/for/slate.com/comments.js'; document.body.appendChild(script1) } document.domain = 'slate.com';checkVisitorId( 'slate.com' );selectMostTab('2');_qoptions={qacct:"p-5cYn7dCzvaeyA"}; if (typeof $ == 'function') { $(document).ready(function() { window._sf_endpt=(new Date()).getTime(); var e = document.createElement('script'); e.setAttribute('language', 'javascript'); e.setAttribute('type', 'text/javascript'); e.setAttribute('src', (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://s3.amazonaws.com/" : "http://") + "static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat.js"); document.body.appendChild(e); }); } document.domain = "slate.com"; Meebo('domReady');Designing Obama, free online. http://slate.me/dv1JzY
Bemoaning the loss of math skills among Americans ... in 1804. http://slate.me/dn5XBA
Read Full Article »