November 8, 2012

Can Jews Write History?

Alex Joffe, Jewish Ideas Daily

In his well-known book Nations and Nationalism since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality, historian Eric Hobsbawm made the remarkable assertion that “no serious historian of nations and nationalism can be a committed political nationalist.”  Being Irish might be compatible with writing serious Irish history, he said; but to be “a Fenian or an Orangeman”—that is, an ultranationalist—“is not so compatible, any more than being a Zionist is compatible with writing a genuinely serious history of the Jews, unless the historian leaves his or her convictions behind when entering the library or the study.” 

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: Jewish Ideas Daily, Judaism

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

October 17, 2013
Judaism Will Only Win If...
David Suissa, Jewish Journal
There’s a nasty food fight going on right now in the Orthodox world between the stringent groups and the more open ones.This latest brouhaha was ignited when the “open Orthodox” Yeshivat Chovevei Torah (YCT) yeshiva... more ››