March 28, 2012

Women Cannot and Will Not Be Priests

Fr. Dwight Longenecker, Patheos

G.K.Chesterton said, “Every argument is a theological argument.” Therefore we must be aware, in the argument for women’s ordination (and indeed in every argument) what forms of argumentation are being made, and where the essential truths lie for Catholics.

Those who argue for women’s ordination usually do so using three forms of argumentation: 1. Utilitarianism 2. Sentimentalism  3. Civil Rights. The utilitarian argument goes like this: “Jane can do the job just as well–and better than a man. She has a degree in theology. She’s a great preacher. She is a sensitive pastor and a good servant of the Lord. Women have shown that they can do any job as well as a man. We need good priests. These women would be great...

Read Full Article ››

TAGGED: Priest , Catholic Church, Women

RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

October 18, 2013
Why We Ordain Women
Tom LeGrand, Associated Baptist Press
We are going to make history this Sunday at Augusta Heights Church in Greenville, SC. For the first time in the 63-year history of the church, we will celebrate the ordination of a woman, Debbie Roper, to the gospel... more ››
October 21, 2013
Could Pope Francis Make Women Cardinals?
David Gibson, WaPo
Could a woman vote for the next pope?Pope Francis has said repeatedly that he wants to see greater roles for women in the Catholic Church, and some argue that he could take a giant step in that direction by appointing women to... more ››
October 17, 2013
'Poor Father' Syndrome
Mark Silk, Religion News Service
A decade ago, I heard a Catholic lawyer who’d made a career of representing religious institutions in sex abuse cases describe the difference between reporting a wayward clergyman to a Methodist or Episcopal bishop versus... more ››